Pas de Deux

When I was 13, I saw The Nutcracker ballet for the first time. It wasn’t my family’s style to go to the ballet, or symphony or theater, but my best friend and her mom had invited my mom and I along. I went in cold without any knowledge of the music or story, and I probably thought I was too cool for it or something, fairies and tutus and such. But the anticipation alone was excitement enough. The whole experience of dressing up, handing over our tickets, finding a seat through the crowd, a live orchestra– all of it was new and exhilarating. I felt immediately elevated; I felt wealthier, smarter, more beautiful; I felt like a classy broad.

As soon as the orchestra played the first several measures and the curtains swept back, I was gone. By thirteen, I had quickly buried my love of fairytales and sense of wonder in favor of a more enlightened and cynical worldview, but The Nutcracker called my bluff. I don’t even know if it was critically good, but I will never know because I was in love with all of it: the costumes, the narrative, the story-telling through dance– all of it was magical. But the moment that transported me was the Pas de Deux. I was sure I had never heard any music so ethereal. I was swept away with its romance and grandeur. When we got home, I picked out the melody on the piano, and later when I received the soundtrack as a Christmas gift, I listened to it over and over again. It was like getting wrapped in a tender whirlwind and lifted off the ground. I regularly listened to that album, just as regularly as Smashing Pumpkins’ Siamese Dream and Tori Amos’s Little Earthquakes.

It wasn’t until I had children that I began to explore more of Tchaikovsky’s work. I excitedly introduced my little girls to Disney’s Sleeping Beauty, which had been my absolute favorite animated movie as a child, only to realize that Disney had borrowed Tchaikovsky’s Sleeping Beauty ballet as its score. Watching that movie as an adult was like finding the source of my own aesthetic: the stylized art inspired by medieval tapestry, the sharply angled faces of the heroes and heroines, the woodland cottage and stately castles, and the score that carried it all on a current through peril and triumph. This was the foundation of beauty for me.

I was thrilled to introduce my children to Tchaikovsky, and while the ballet is still expensive, many ballets are available on disc, which is how we watch The Nutcracker every year, and how we’ve all seen Sleeping Beauty and Swan Lake. I have loved watching it capture their imagination as they bound about the room copying the dances and memorizing the melodies, and then when they’re older, discussing themes, motifs, and artistic choices. It renews the wonder for me. Gradually, I take one child at a time to the ballet (or live theater) as we can afford it so they can experience the heightened anticipation of a performance, and possibly be transported by a song.

Even now, thirty years later, something happens to me when I listen to the Pas de Deux, like the invisible string that connects me to my Creator pulls taut and draws my attention. I’ve thought a lot about why. I think it captures the overwhelming feeling of longing and desire, and the exclusivity of romance when the world passes away and the only other body you’re aware of is that of your lover. There’s safety, protection, and strength in its exclusivity and one-ness. The continuous, climbing scales within the song that ascend and descend capture the moments of anticipation, of joy and delight, at times of sorrow, and ultimate ecstasy of love. The grandeur of the song– and the moment in the ballet– captures the pursuit of God the Lover for us, and the full realization of our purpose in communing fully with Him.

Going to the ballet was transformative. It opened up a whole new arena of visual and musical storytelling, of beauty incarnate in the human form. There is a cathedral-like quality in the ballet, a sacramentality where conceptual beauty meets the human form and music tells a story to draw our attention elsewhere, not to escape, but to connect more fully with our humanity.

the God of Grit

O great mystery,

and wonderful sacrament,

that animals should see the Lord born,

lying in a crib;

The medieval hymn, O Magnum Mysterium, expresses awe at the humility of Christ’s birth. That the birth of the King of Kings should be first witnessed to by beasts of burden, and that the spouse of the Holy Spirit lies on hard ground amidst scratchy hay to labor– this is a magnum mysterium, a great mystery.

During different stages of my life, I have pondered different aspects of Christ’s birth during the Advent and Christmas seasons. As a young adult, the wonder and majesty struck me; as a young mother, the discomfort and peril struck me; at other times, the historical and cultural circumstances have struck me. But this Christmas, it has been poignantly sensory. I am there experiencing the stench of animal urine and dung, the smell and scratch of hay, the frigid night air, the veil of darkness, the base life-sounds of bleating and newborn cries.

This past year I have tried to be honest and receptive in my relationship with God, which has revealed a lot of repressed anger and hurt towards God. I had to work through the shame of feeling angry before I could actually confront the origins of this anger. Interiorly, I wearied, stopped wrestling the darkness, and I’m now just sitting with it. While that’s necessary, it’s dark and cold here at times. But I know this is part of deliverance and healing.

It’s been liberating to stop forcing emotions, like pulling cellophane over a bucket of muck. Right now, Mass is an act of obedience; Communion is a still, quiet moment at the cross. But this is an improvement from running out of Church during the consecration, which is where I was a year ago. Part of that healing has been peeling away the angelic, gilded depictions of Christ and the Church, and discovering the grit. Only then do I see myself and the life God has walked with me through. Only then do I remember that God indeed has been Emmanuel, God with me– not just in consolation and revelation, but He has been faithful in all things, all places, even under the cold veil of night. I don’t know if I believe that yet, but at least I can imagine that I will get there.

What does it mean that God chose to be born in a dank, stench-filled cave, surrounded by dumb animals? If Mary was the beloved of His heart, why would he allow her to give birth in cold, pungent darkness? Magnum Mysterium opens with, “O great mystery”. This, like so much of Christ’s life, is a mystery which theologians debate and mystics contemplate. But what we can know with the same senses that Christ incarnated, is that His birth, while miraculous and mysterious, was also one of stench and grit.

This simple reality makes me feel loved. As John of the Cross wrote, “this delight within your Bride / Would great be increased, / If the flesh she is endowed with / She saw you also shared”. The stench and grit that I am working through is there with baby Jesus and the Holy Family. I will sit with them in the dark, chilly cave, in the great mystery, and trust that salvation is here.

O Blessed Virgin, whose womb

was deemed worthy to bear

the Lord Jesus Christ.

Alleluia!

my new old love: BOOKS

{I originally intended to post this at the end of 2019, but it got lost under a stack of drafts. This is my 2018-19 reading list!

I am a jilted reader. For one, I am a very slow reader. I read out-loud in my head, sounding out every word. I do the voices. I have to underline things and make notes, otherwise I won’t remember what I just read. Sometimes I’ll be reading for a good ten minutes before I realize I’ve been thinking about an old “Friends” episode and completely missed what happened over the past five pages. So you can imagine how difficult it is to read with lots of distractions (i.e. children) around. My husband, on the other hand, is an incredible reader. He has an amazing ability to tune out everything (and I mean EVERYTHING) when he’s reading. He has an astounding memory: if he wants to share something he read, maybe even years ago, he can quickly thumb through the book and find the passage he wanted. Me, on the other hand: people will talk about a great scene, character, dialogue, or fact from a book, I’ll respond and ask what book it’s from, only to find out that I have actually read that book! (Only, I clearly didn’t actually read that book….)

I wasn’t always like that. I used to love reading. I would run into things because I was reading so much of the time. But somewhere around the age of 10 I just kind of stopped, unless it was assigned reading (which I usually skimmed). Of course, during my conversion I read a ton of books about everything Catholic, ate those up like candy. And then for years I was reading picture books to my children (which I love because, you know, all the voices).

I mostly struggle with fiction. It has to really grab my attention, otherwise I start getting distracted by all the useful things I could be doing with my time. I could quickly name the fictional books I have read in the past 16 years (which is when I graduated college and no longer had required reading): Anna Karenina (read that on my honeymoon and into my first pregnancy), Eleni (read that while nursing my first baby), and the High King series (read those while pregnant and nursing my fifth baby). The first Harry Potter book, and half of the second. Yep.

I’m much better with non-fiction. It feels less like a waste of time. If I’m learning something, acquiring factual (or mostly factual) information then I can justify a good read. Over the years this had been sporadic spiritual reading (I Believe in Love, My Mother Zelie, Advent of the Heart, 1000 Gifts, various Al-Anon literature).

But something happened to me a couple years ago. It was … I don’t know… maybe a mini-crisis of faith? A new batch of challenges popped up quite suddenly and all at the same time and I didn’t have a vocabulary for it. I mentioned this to a friend, something about beauty and aesthetic in the Church and the role of women– none of which was said coherently, so his fluid and fitting reply could only have been the Holy Spirit using that golden moment to open a floodgate.

At first I caught the names Houselander (whose effect on me I’ve written about elsewhere), Edith Stein, and a slew of “vons”. The year that followed was enormously important for my whole being- my mind, heart,and soul. I rediscovered a love for reading. And not just reading, but contemplative reading, reading that inspired my interrupted prayer life. I know this is old news for most people, but it awakened me right at a time I needed it.

This past year I finally read a book that has been recommended to me for years: Sigrid Undsett’s Kristin Lavransdatter. Chances are, you’ve already discovered this treasure, but if you haven’t… READ IT. I’ve never read a novel that encapsulates what it means to be a woman in all her stages of life as this book. Undset possesses a deep understanding of humanity. Her characters remain unchanging in their unique personalities, though altered by their life experiences.

Another book that I read this past year that I would recommend as a life-changer is Love Alone is Credible. I know people have some hang-ups with Hans Urs von Balthasar, and though I’ve heard the reasons, I don’t understand how anyone could not appreciate this poet-theologian’s explanation of anything trinitarian. His work has changed the way I see God and the way I understand how He sees me, if that makes sense. And Adrienne von Speyr’s Handmaid of the Lord is a rich companion text (and I’ve written about that more). It doesn’t directly relate to Love Alone is Credible, but her reflections on the life of Mary fit beautifully alongside Balthasar’s meaty text.

In brief…

My 2018-19 Book List

  • Kristin Lavrandsatter by Sigrid Undset
  • Handmaid of the Lord by Adrienne von Speyr
  • A Key to Balthasar by Aidan Nichols
  • Love Alone is Credible by Hans Urs von Balthasar
  • The Privelege of Being a Woman by Alice von Hildebrand
  • Into the Deep by Abigail Favale
  • The Passion of the Infant Christ by Caryll Houselander
  • Humility by Dietrich von Hildebrand
  • That Nothing May Be Lost by Rev. Paul Scalia
  • Awaking Beauty: The Art of Eyvind Earle

St. Hildegard of Bingen

Feast Day: December 17

St. Hildegard was a 12th century Benedictine abbess, mystic, poet, composer, physician, Doctor of the Church– in short, a remarkable woman. I don’t know much about her and I’m only just now beginning to seek her out, having caught interest from a convert-friend of mine who loves her.

Pope Benedict XVI said this of St. Hildegard, “Let us always invoke the Holy Spirit, so that he may inspire in the Church holy and courageous women like Saint Hildegard of Bingen who, developing the gifts they have received from God, make their own special and valuable contribution to the spiritual development of our communities and of the Church in our time.”

Though her original feast day is September 17, it has been moved to December 17, which is convenient since much of her poetry and song is fitting for the contemplative period before Christmas when we are accompanied by the O Antiphons. Below is a beautiful choice for the season, though there are many others worth seeking out.

Ave, Generosa

Hail, girl of a noble house,
shimmering and unpolluted,
you pupil in the eye of chastity,
you essence of sanctity,
which was pleasing to God.

For the Heavenly potion was poured into you,
in that the Heavenly word
received a raiment of flesh in you.

You are the lily that dazzles,
whom God knew
before all others.

O most beautiful and delectable one;
how greatly God delighted in you!
In the clasp of His fire
He implanted in you so that
His son might be suckled by you.

Thus your womb held joy,
when the harmony of all Heaven chimed out from you,
because, Virgin, you carried the son of God
whence your chastity blazed in God.

Your flesh has known delight,
like the grassland touched by dew
and immersed in its freshness:
so it was with you, O mother of all joy.

Now let the sunrise of joy be over all Ecclesia,
and let it resound in music
for the sweetest Virgin,
Mary compelling all praise,
mother of God. Amen.

St. John of the Cross

Feast Day: December 14

As the beloved 16th century Carmelite poet Juan de la Cruz’s feast day happens right after Guadalupe and St. Lucia, his is celebrated simply in our home: just a reading of one of his poems at evening prayer. All of his poems are fitting for Advent, but a few in particular are especially thought-provoking for the season. Below is a favorite.

Ballad VII: Of the Incarnation

Now as the season approached

(the date love specified)

for the ransom paid in full,

the shackles struck from the bride

who was forfeit under the law

law-giver Moses made,

the father with melting heart

after this fashion said:

My son, I have found you a bride

of your very sort, you’ll find.

You will have good cause to know

You are two of a noble kind,

differing only in flesh

(what are you but a child of sky?).

But the course of true love hints

here is a law will apply:

Lovers long to become

as identical as they may;

for the more the two are one,

gayer the gala day.

Delight and love in the bride

speedily would increase

(no question here, my son)

if she saw you a man of flesh.

I have no will but yours,

the son to the father replied.

My glory is all in this:

I do, and you decide.

It couldn’t be other than just

I follow as you provide.

How better let all men see

Your charity far and wide?

How better blazon your might,

sweet reason and deep mind?

I’ll carry word to the world,

news of a novel kind:

news of beauty and peace,

of sovereignty unconfined.

I go to be close to the bride

and to take on my back (for it’s strong)

the weight of the wearisome toil

that bent the poor back for so long.

To make certain-sure of her life

I’ll manfully die in her place,

and drawing her safe from the pit

present her alive to your face.

I-want-to-roo-you-playlist-for-Valentine’s-Day

A month ago, the glittering foil heart balloons popped up all over the grocery store to herald in the season of… love, is it? Or a 6-year-old girl’s fantasy world where everything’s pink and candy-flavored. Disclaimer: I don’t really like Valentine’s Day. I don’t see the point. You should tell the people you love them that you love them everyday. And I can’t help but to be a cynic about what a marketing empire it is.

I stopped enjoying Valentine’s Day right around the time it became awkward to exchange valentines. I was never much of a pink hearts and red roses kind of girl anyways. The only really great thing about Valentine’s Day is the chocolate. But that should be permissible and good anytime of the year. (The goodness of chocolate is just plain old science. Even during Lent, the very dark chocolate with no dairy is a worthwhile substitute—just ask the Sisters of the Holy Theophany in Olympia, Washington). It seemed like a cowardly cop-out that someone would declare one’s love on Valentine’s Day—I mean, come on, be original. And then when I learned about the actual St. Valentine, the gig was up.

I first set out to make an awkward-love-songs-playlist, which was highly entertaining, but started to get, frankly, creepy. There are a lot of pretty bad love songs, like songs that should be arrested and tried for real crimes. I have to include a few that are just amusing, then I’ll move on. Here is a mini-playlist (just enough for a good laugh) of the worst-but-not-too-creepy love songs:

  • “I Fooled Around and Fell in Love” – Elvin Bishop… The man we all want, who says he’s been with “a million” girls, but is ready to settle down. Ewwwwwww.
  • “I Would do Anything For Love (But I Won’t Do That)” – Meat Loaf… Has anyone ever found out what “that” is? Not sure I want to know…
  • “Just the Way You Are” – Billy Joel… Now, I love Billy Joel. But this song is not really a love song. He’s basically saying he doesn’t want her to surprise him or grow as a person, just wants her to be quiet and pretty, and to leave him alone.
  • “I’ll Make Love to You” – Boyz II Men… Ultimately, more poetic subtlety should be employed than “I’ll take my clothes off, too.” Mmm, yeeeahhh, or not.
  • “Lovefool” – the Cardigans… I used to love this song because it’s just fun to dance to; it’s on the Romeo & Juliet soundtrack which I had been in the habit of listening to since high school. But it was my daughter who pointed out, with appropriate disgust, “Uh, is she basically saying she wants him to pretend that he loves her?” Ooh, yes, [parent fail] and skip.

and now, to the good stuff:

But I am not a love cynic. I believe in love, baby. I believe in True Love, the Author of Love, the saving Love of Jesus Christ. But that’s another post. Related, however, is the love of Valentine’s Day, the kind of love where we taste Divine Love, the kind of love that keeps this beautiful world populated.

Without further ado, here is a solid hour of I-want-to-roo-you-love songs (please, consider these in your Valentine’s Day cards instead of the usual cheese!):

  • “500 Miles” – The Proclaimers… Such a clever way to say “I love you”! Though I’m not sure what heavering is… anybody?
  • “Sweetest Devotion” – Adele
  • “Crazy Love” – Van Morrison… It was a toss-up with Van Morrison’s “Tupelo Honey”. I could make a Van Morrison love song playlist. He writes the best love-lyrics. Ever. (see “Sweet Thing”, “You’re My Woman”, “Warm Love”)
  • “Every Little Thing She Does is Magic” – The Police
  • “Blood and Tears” – Joseph
  • “How Sweet it Is” – James Taylor
  • “The Way You Look Tonight” – Frank Sinatra… Classic. Period.
  • “When the Stars Go Blue” – Ryan Adams
  • “One Fine Thing – Harry Connick Jr.
  • “Settle Down” – Kimbra… It’s like the Catholic-dating love song.
  • “For Once in My Life” – Stevie Wonder
  • “Winter Birds” – Ray LaMontagne
  • “I Wanna Roo You” – Van Morrison
  • “Tip of My Tongue” – Civil Wars
  • “Lover, You Should Have Come Over” – Jeff Buckley
  • “Bring it on Home To Me” – Sam Cooke




my transition-out-of-the-holidays-and-still-feel-jolly playlist

“Intergalactic Planetary” – Beastie Boys … Maybe it’s an overdose of saccharine holiday music, but come January I really needed a little Beastie, and this is one of the few Beastie Boys songs I can listen to with kids around.

“Clap Yo’ Hands” – Ella Fitzgerald … Ella can sing anything; she’s a staple in my house. This jazzy Gershwin tune is just fun.

“Baby Be Mine” – Michael Jackson… I mean, the whole Thriller album, for reals.

“You Are the Best Thing” – Ray LaMontagne… you had me at [trumpet fanfare].

“Don’t Stop” – Fleetwood Mac … If you can believe it, I did aerobics to Fleetwood Mac in the 8th grade, not kidding you, a legit P.E. elective.

“Gumboots” – Paul Simon … That line: “you don’t feel you could love me, but I feel you could” is such a great pick-up line! If you’re single, please go out and use it, and let me know how it goes.

“Little of Your Love”- Haim … I just found out about this band this past summer. If Heart and Bananarama had a musical love-child, it would be Haim.

“Beautiful Day”- U2 … because it is, because it is.

“I Will Wait” – Mumford & Sons … You can totally polka to this song, just sayin’.

“Mandolin Wind” – Rod Stewart … “all I’ve got is yours, except of course, my steel guitar” (love that).

 “You Make my Dreams”- Hall & Oates … Dare you not to dance to that one, even with an over-tired toddler wandering around trying your patience.

“Your Wings” – Lauren Daigle … she’s singing to Jesus, bonus.

“It’s Oh So Quiet” – Bjork … Pure fun.

“Can’t Stop the Feeling” – Justin Timberlake … and this is when you dance your brains out.